"I" Titles
- I Am Listening
- I Belong to Jesus
- I Can Trust Him
- I Cannot Sing the Old Songs
- I Feel Thy Angel Spirit
- I Had a Little Doggy
- I Had a Little Nut Tree
- I Love My Love
- I Must Find God
- I Need Thee Every Hour
- I Saw Three Ships
- I Shall Find My Savior There
- I Shall See Him
- I Think, When I Read That Sweet Story
- I Wandered by the Sea-Beat Shore
- I Want My Life to Tell
- I Will Be True to Thee
- I Will Sing a Lullaby
- I'm a Pilgrim
- I'm Nearer My Home Today
- I'll Hang My Harp on a Willow Tree
- I've Been Rambling All the Night
- I've Found a Friend
- I've Left the Snow-Clad Hills
- I've Something Sweet to Tell You
- If All the World Were Paper
- If Love Were What the Rose Is
- Illinois (Illinois State Song)
- In Dulci Jubilo
- In Heavenly Love Abiding
- In Old Madrid
- In the Gloaming
- In the Glow of Some Glad Morning
- In the Shadow of the Cross
- In the Sweet By and By
- Independent Farmer, The
- Integer Vitae
- Is John Smith Within?
- Is There Room for Me?
- It Came Upon the Midnight Clear
- It Is His Will
- It's a Way We Have at Old Harvard
- Italian Cradle Song (Dormi, Dormi)